Custom Comet: The Niche Art of Pin Designing

Written by Eleanna Grosz
Published on October 4th, 2026
Based in Portland, Oregon. Custom Comet specializes in customized merchandise, including pins, air fresheners, patches, stickers, and more. I had the pleasure of speaking with both the founder Sean Turner and the Art Director Savannah Price about this niche world.
They have a small team of around 20 artists from across the country. You can find some of their merchandise right here created for UP Magazine.

Turner seemed particularly passionate about Custom Comet’s subsidiary that specializes in pins: “All Star Trading Pins.” Turner seemed particularly infatuated with the art of pin design. “It’s a unique industry that not a lot of people are doing, and I think we pick products based on how hard they are.” As Turner explained, “Trading Pins are basically for youth sports: They go to these tournaments, and they trade pins….It’s extremely competitive to have the best design…. So these teams come up to us and they say: Hey, we’re from Chicago, and we’re going to this tournament on this date. Here’s a little bit about our team, here’s our logo.’ And we’ll create these crazy pins with moving parts! It’s all done by artists here.”
Turner seemed particularly passionate about Custom Comet’s subsidiary that specializes in pins: “All Star Trading Pins.”
Art Director Savannah Price elaborates about what the artistic process is like. “So my job, along with the art team, is to create something that is unique and stands out for these teams. Whether it’s something unique to their hometown or their school…. Anything that would be special for them when they’re going to these tournaments across the country.” Price’s personal art can be found on Custom Comet’s website or on her Instagram page.

Price is very passionate about what she does and loves being able to have a creative job. “It’s great! I feel very lucky…Not many people get to do what they love every single day, so I love getting to use my creativity day-in-day-out and refine my skills in this career path. Also independently as an artist I enjoy just getting better and better with each pin that’s made or logo or air freshener. It’s great, I love it!”
More recently, the trading pin industry has become more intense and demanding.
More recently, the trading pin industry has become more intense and demanding. Teams are intent on having the best pin at tournaments, and sometimes 3 or 4 types of pins in different categories or levels. The teams want their pins to be bigger, more colorful, and more complex. Custom Comet and its affiliate “All Star Trading Pins” are keeping pace with this demand.
An unfortunate negative byproduct of the increased frenzy to get the best pin is team officials looking to AI for help designing pins. They expect the AI design to be replicated exactly, even though the AI design was made without an understanding of the limitations of pin design. As Turner explained: “What AI produces for a design isn’t usually something that can be converted into an enamel pin. Enamel pins are sort of intricate. You have to fill it in with paint; you can’t have overlapping colors or gradients….”

Turner believes this is the biggest challenge for the company’s artists. “Where a customer’s like – ‘Oh this looks really cool in AI,’ and it’s just not something we can physically make into a pin.” Over 5 years, things went from a team parent communicating with Custom Comet with a screenshot of a sketch on a napkin, and allowing its artists to transform the nascent idea into a full-blown pin, to AI creating impossibly intricate designs, and Custom Comet’s artists having to negotiate the customer down or try to step up and figure out how to approximate the AI design.
“I feel like this is one of the few businesses that has a lot of real artists on staff. I feel like a lot of companies are shifting to AI, I think that kind of separates us from these other companies.”
The company prides itself on having its products designed authentically by talented artists, as opposed to using generative AI, as Price explained. “I feel like this is one of the few businesses that has a lot of real artists on staff. I feel like a lot of companies are shifting to AI, I think that kind of separates us from these other companies. When you go out to these competitions for who has the coolest design, it’s not just a computer throwing together some generic template. It’s actually a real artist who knows what they’re doing…. Each of the designers does it themselves; there’s no AI used. It’s just a very intimate process working together to get them the perfect product.”

Turner decried the use of AI, noting that a product using AI “has got no personality or soul to it” and saying products made with AI never look as nice, “and you can always tell.” But this ironically made him optimistic that customers’ demand for using AI would come to an end. Already he notes that there is a contingent of customers that make clear that they want no AI used to make their products. “I think there is an anti-AI contingent out there of consumers who just don’t want it because it feels cheap. Usually when you buy a piece of art, you want something that’s actually made by a person.”
For Turner and Price, the frenzy of tournament season isn’t just business, it’s a small, stubborn defense of the idea that things made by hand still matter.
For Turner and Price, the frenzy of tournament season isn’t just business, it’s a small, stubborn defense of the idea that things made by hand still matter. As trading pins get bigger, brighter, and more elaborate each year, Custom Comet’s bet is that the artistry behind them, not some algorithm, is what keeps kids trading pins in dugouts and parking lots in the first place. Whether or not the “anti-AI contingent” Turner describes grows into the norm, one thing seems certain: As long as there are tournaments to travel to and pins to trade, there will be artists at Custom Comet translating napkin sketches into something a kid can actually hold in their hand.