UP3 - Jeff Beler and the Underhill Crew
Written by Christina Elia

This article was originally published in UP’s Issue 3: Community & Culture, published Ocober 2020. Order a copy here & read it in print!
I’ve spent many a brisk morning watching curator Jeff Beler command his troops of artists. His jurisdiction: the facades of public elementary schools throughout Prospect Heights, Gotham Academy of the Arts, and Underhill Walls, a collection of wood panels on the corner of St. John’s Place and Underhill Avenue. My boyfriend Paolo Tolentino is an unofficial member of Beler’s crew, having painted two Underhill editions and participated in projects at P.S. 9 and P.S. 321. Though I’d been familiar with Beler prior to my relationship, our affinity strengthened over grit and glasses of wine, huddled on Underhill Avenue as his curations changed with the seasons. I approached him about writing a story when I knew UP’s third theme would be community.
Beler agreed without hesitation. During an unusually warm day in early winter, we arranged to meet at Washington Commons, a Prospect Heights bar littered with locals. Naturally, he made the rounds to greet familiar faces before we proceeded to our seats. Socializing proved second nature for the burgeoning Brooklyn personality, a matter confirmed any time we walked a few blocks in his neighborhood. Kids and adults alike saluted him with a friendly smile. An active resident for sixteen years, Beler had ample time to make his mark on Prospect Heights, now in flux due to ongoing re-zoning issues and a wave of affluent new residents. But such a reputation isn’t procured overnight. Unbeknownst to Beler’s eclectic background, I wondered what advanced his ascension from street art bystander to active participant. The curator recalled his nomadic youth.
“There weren’t many murals back then,” Beler explained. “Psycho City represented the old school: authentic and hardcore.”
“I moved around a lot. First to L.A., then to Phoenix, and back to L.A.,” Beler said. “Eventually I moved back East, but I still miss the West Coast.”
His love for graffiti blossomed in San Francisco. A Pittsburgh native working in design, Beler landed a job devising storefronts for Banana Republic’s visual department. His first encounter with street art happened at Psycho City, a Bay Area parking lot open to taggers. Graffiti crowded every inch of the lawless zone, extending from the barricades down to the manhole covers. Camera in tow and ready to explore, Beler ran into legendary writer Sloke One, and the two instantly struck up a companionship. Sloke gave him an introductory crash course on the San Francisco streets. Before long, they became roommates, and Beler solidified his interest in the flowering art form.
“There weren’t many murals back then,” Beler explained. “Psycho City represented the old school: authentic and hardcore.”
Craving a change of pace, Beler moved to New York in 1995. He settled in Carroll Gardens, then a predominantly Italian-American neighborhood, and began working in Ralph Lauren’s visual department. Oscillating between different positions and various freelance gigs, he eventually resigned to go back to school for a degree in decorative arts. Beler’s curiosity about street art fell to the back-burner as he settled within his luxury niche. Recalling his early years in New York, he reflected on one neighborhood he felt particularly drawn to: SoHo. Its alleyways rotated with swarms of stickers and wheatpastes near-daily, different from the graffiti Beler had been accustomed to in San Francisco.
“I didn’t really go out of my way to look for it,” Beler admitted. “I just liked to document. Taking pictures was my thing.”
Curating hadn’t occurred to him until he lived in Prospect Heights. When Beler first moved to the neighborhood, it was entirely devoid of murals, inhabited by the occasional graffiti tag or throw-up. In 2014, he noticed a dilapidated panel on St. John’s Street in need of some sprucing up. Sloke had introduced him to New York artists Meresone, See tf, Danielle Mastrion, and NMEoner, all of whom he felt a kinship with. He just had to secure the wall. Utilizing his community network, he succeeded in contacting the building’s owner, who gave him permission to paint the panels. Beler noted how far a little compassion can go, claiming he formed his interpersonal connections simply by being affable. Neighbors call him the ‘Mayor of Washington Avenue.’
“I thought, ‘why not, I live here,’” Beler told me. “I don’t want to just put my blinders on and keep walking. I want to be involved.”
After witnessing his Washington Avenue wall’s success, Beler sought more opportunities around the neighborhood. He curated a show in the back of a card shop, organized miscellaneous walls with NMEoner, and continued making beneficial connections. This included local artist Justin Winslow, who lives a few blocks away from where Beler’s street art career was inaugurated. Winslow had taken note of all the new walls popping up, piquing his interest in the medium. Feeling inspired by the neighborhood’s new artistic ambiance, he approached Beler in hopes of working together on future projects. He didn’t realize a lifelong friendship would soon develop.
“I remember thinking, ‘who is this creative whirlwind?’” Winslow recalled. “He seemed in charge, telling artists what to do, where to be. I thought, ‘I need to get to know this guy.’”
Winslow had no formal background in street art. Originally from Atlanta, he moved to New York to pursue a career in motion graphics, which is still his main source of income. He’s worked with Sesame Street, The Barbie Movie, and even pitched a show to Nickelodeon. Most of his current designs depict his cat Gus, an adorable Persian whose piercing gaze conveys otherworldly secrets. Winslow has always considered himself chameleon-like in his approach, utilizing art as a means of experimentation. He’s painted commissioned portraits, tiny napkin cartoons, and plastered his feline’s face on almost any form of merchandise imaginable. Snarky humor, cute characters, and pop culture are a few commonalities among his depictions, all embodying his signature animated touch.
“I’ve never been able to shake my childlike, whimsical appeal,” Winslow told me. “And that’s what’s so positive about it. It’s populist, colorful, and fun.”
His work matured when he met Beler. Street art presented an exotic enclave yet to be explored, both emblematic and democratic. Winslow had internalized the contrast between his corporate workplace and his new medium-of-choice, causing him to suppress his creative urges. Whenever he felt inspired, he instead preserved his energy, unleashing it when he had artistic autonomy. His varied skill set produced an impressive portfolio. After showing Beler a few samples for consideration, he soon became inducted into the curator’s legion. Winslow now calls Beler his “brother from another mother,” which is comically self-aware, considering the pair’s uncanny resemblance.
“Other art worlds can be so insular. Street art is much more collaborative,” Winslow commented. “If you’re stuck, you can ask someone for advice, or even to borrow paint. That’s really special to me.”
Underhill Walls followed shortly after. Winslow worked with Beler on the first version in 2015, a venture whose initiation required extensive groundwork. Beler used his contacts to reach the building’s owner but installing seventeen wood panels on its exterior amounted to a bigger challenge. After recruiting professional help, the abandoned lot nearly conformed to his vision. It just needed a few coats of paint. Even without a clear-cut plan, the curator followed his gut when organizing his first lot. He teamed up with Love Heals, a non-profit AIDS organization, secured sponsorship from Detroit-based company Plutonium Spray Paint, and finally decided on a theme: Zodiac. Beler gathered a team of talented artists to fulfill his artistic aspiration.
“I visualized it. As a creative person, I just knew what I wanted to see,” Beler explained. “Curating themed murals seemed strange at the time, but everyone felt enthusiastic about picking their sign.”
Beler’s event marked a turning point for the Prospect Heights community. Participating muralists included Jeff Henriquez, Col Wallnuts, URNewYork, Rob Plater, and Zimad, each adapting their style to a different astrological sign. Hoping to address the stigma associated with sexuality and sexually transmitted diseases, the campaign received media attention from publications throughout New York, including the NY Observer and the BKLYNER. Neighbors gathered to watch the work-in-progress and stood by fascinated, curiously questioning its inception. Beler had introduced a new aesthetic to the neighborhood’s banal landscape: life-sized portraits, deconstructed scorpions, magical centaurs. Winslow collaborated with Carmelo Ferraro on a fierce depiction of a lion, Danielle Mastrion adorned her Pisces female figure with a crown formed from fish, and Zukie duplicated her signature rotund character to represent Gemini.
“I saw what it did for the neighborhood. Everyone kept saying ‘thank you so much,’ and it really instilled a sense of joy,” Beler said. “I felt proud to live down the street. This is my community.”
Beler’s posse bonded over a veneration for his cause. Mentioning close ties to the LGBTQ+ community, Zukie had been eager to help further the curator’s goal. She previously met him through mutual friends and quickly warmed to his generous disposition. When she discovered the concept behind his first Underhill campaign, she realized her iridescent blotches could corral a new dwelling place. Particularly fond of speech bubbles and perceptible heartstrings, Zukie’s genderfluid characters colorfully harmonized with others from Beler’s brigade, all of whom incorporated brilliant splashes of color. Neighborhood kids rubbernecked at the sight of her mirrored Gemini illustration, which depicted multihued twins puking up rainbows. The sometimes sweet, occasionally sassy creations personify the artist’s fluctuating emotional spectrum. Beler took an immediate interest in her chromatic configurations.
“We hit it off instantly,” Zukie explained. “I love new experiences, so I was really excited to be a part of Underhill.”
Hailing from Queens, Zukie grew up under graffiti’s influence. She later translated this adoration into her trademark ‘Zukies,’ her namesake blob-like formations. Many feature a distinct facial expression or an empty speech bubble, signaling a message beyond verbal recognition. Zukie clarified how her past as an emergency room worker made her privy to a plethora of gestural possibilities. Her characters convey nuanced sentiments through straightforward mannerisms: joyful eyes, twisted frowns, bashful head bows. Emotional bonds are paramount in her pictorial realm, secrets almost non-existent. Even characters clouded by rainbows disclose a deeper definition. Each Zukie wears their heart on their sleeve, both literally and figuratively.
“How can you express a smile?” Zukie questioned. “My art really developed by working somewhere with hundreds of emotions in one day.”
Zukie experienced a tempestuous introduction to muralism. Emerging from a multimedia background in toy-making and fine art, she noted a cold reception from peers regarding her street art-related inquiries, such as finding legal walls. Fellow muralists she consulted scorned her request for advice and insisted any real street artist could locate a wall without assistance. To further her own craft, Zukie then turned toward the Internet, teaching herself to master spray paint and its various techniques. She now applies her own experience as an incentive to educate other artists, utilizing her Instagram and YouTube platform to make educational how-to videos on a range of art-related topics. She also works with a Long Island-based festival titled “Under the Tent,” where she teaches children to paint using prototypes of her own toys. Zukie wants her art to inspire faith instead of antipathy.
“When I first started, I didn’t have anyone to talk to. I felt hopeless. I don’t want that for others,” Zukie said. “To me, community means helping one another. I do that with knowledge.”
Beler had similar aspirations for Prospect Heights. After stumbling through his next few Underhill renditions, the curator questioned his flight path. Then, in 2017, an unexpected tragedy overtook the neighborhood. Elementary school P.S.9 contacted Beler to ask if he could curate a mural for a student named Clara Ely who had just died of brain cancer. After receiving a list of her favorite objects, Beler arranged to decorate the facade of Ely’s alma mater with a S.T.E.A.M. theme: science, technology, engineering, art, and math. Jeff Henriquez riffed off a Picasso painting in the school’s courtyard; characters by Chris RWK, Zero Productivity, Nite Owl, and Antennae inhabited crevices throughout the building. Winslow painted his mascot Gus crossing over a giant rainbow, Zukie replicated her twins, and Subway Doodle turned dumpsters to split-tongued monsters. In total, the project spanned an entire summer, and the work of over 70 artists. Nothing as ambitious had ever been accomplished in the Brooklyn education system.
“I felt torn. It was a very emotional topic.” Beler confessed. “But I realized I had left a legacy for this girl. I had brought attention to her plight.”
Clara Ely’s tribute caused a domino effect. Word of Beler’s work spread following the completion of P.S. 9, garnering his efforts more attention. “Clara’s Garden,” – the name given to an area comprising murals and a selection of healing plants – came to be featured in a documentary highlighting her story, proceeding the production of a limited-run picture book. St. Francis College even reached out to Beler to commission murals for the school’s military office, and he then received more offers from local elementary schools around Brooklyn, including P.S. 321 and B.A.S.E. (Brooklyn Academy of Science and Environment). Beler applied for his vendor license to officialize the process, and he eventually generated his own one-of-a-kind occupation. He’s now listed in the Department of Education as ‘Curator of School Murals.’
“I don’t really have an educational background, so the fact that I got accepted surprised me,” Beler said. “Every project is different. I’m still on a semi-freelance basis.”
P.S. 321 became Beler’s next undertaking. Classes gave suggestions for concepts they’d like to see materialized in a mural, and their ideas led to a complex anti-bullying design called ‘The Wall of Kindness.’ Interwoven by over ten artists, the twelve-foot synthesis of goodwill contained positive tidbits underscoring a better tomorrow, a glimmer of optimism for posterity. Winslow painted a kaleidoscopic dragon to center the composition, and its vivid scales receded from fiery red to green, orange, and yellow. Riding on its back: Paulie Nassar’s plump pandas, Calicho’s humpback whale, and Raddington Falls’ LEGO-inspired bubble blower. Flying pigs summoned childlike imagination, monsters held hands around a globe, and glittering unicorns proclaimed “you’re a star!” Other words of encouragement by My Life in Yellow and Marco Santini filled the blank space between characters.
“Our theme was ‘No Place for Hate,’” Beler explained. “The message is great, and the flow is absolutely beautiful. It’s been one of my favorites so far.”
I sat on the sidelines the Saturday P.S. 321 underwent most of its rebranding, which gave me plenty of time to eavesdrop on unsuspecting children mesmerized by the artistic process. While witnessing Beler’s effects firsthand, I also had time to acquaint myself with his painter platoon, which included well-known illustrator Subway Doodle. Due to his child’s enrollment in the school, Subway Doodle had a greater investment in P.S. 321’s beautification, elevating him to near-celebrity status in the presence of hundreds of chattering tweens. Beside his signature monsters emerged his rendition of local canine personalities Scout and Teddy, who were painted in matching superhero costumes. Kids squealed at the sight of the beloved pups rocketing to the moon. When Subway Doodle and I met up for an interview months later, I inquired about their origin.
“They belong to a teacher at P.S 321, who also happens to be my neighbor,” Subway Doodle informed me. “Every student who has gone through her class knows Scout and Teddy.”
Subway Doodle’s artistic roots predate his ties to Park Slope. Formally educated in realism, his style slingshot between still life and cartoon characters before he ultimately pushed art aside to focus on raising his family. He later rekindled his zeal and finally embraced his hand tremor, which had been a significant source of shame throughout his career. Instagram then catalyzed his distinguished moniker. One day, he photographed his surroundings in the subway, and illustrated a character he’d developed from an unearthed sketchbook. He reiterated the process until his account went viral, gaining thousands of followers virtually overnight. Having already painted walls prior to his hiatus, the artist yearned to return to his street art foundation. Subway Doodle met Beler after posting a call for legal work on social media.
“He actually rejected my first sketch for P.S. 9,” Subway Doodle disclosed. “I’m glad he did, though, because I liked my second option so much better.”
In addition to plastering monolithic monsters on P.S. 9 and P.S. 321, Subway Doodle painted two iterations of Underhill, my favorite being his latest riff on Beler’s book theme: Where The Beastie Things Are. His characteristic contortions squeeze between crevices throughout the five boroughs, manic eyes bulging from their dislocated sockets. Instead of choosing between art and his family, he now fuses both elements, enlisting his children as painting assistants on numerous occasions. (His girlfriend’s youngest son earned bragging rights at P.S. 321 by helping Subway Doodle put the finishing touches on a globe circled by monsters.) At home, Subway Doodle takes a citizen’s duty to the next level by babysitting local pets, including Scout, Teddy, and a black cat belonging to his downstairs neighbor. Every day the gentle creatures nuzzle into his embrace as if it’s home.
“I have this tiny world of both people and animals,” Subway Doodle laughed. “That’s my community.”
Beler’s ambition has also extended to students at Gotham Academy of the Arts, where he mentors high schoolers to advance their creative capabilities. To strengthen their interest in muralism, he’s even allowed students to paint a Marvel and DC-Comics-inspired mural in Gotham’s classrooms, a tongue-in-cheek nod to symbolize its focus on artistic activities. He also aims to directly immerse high schoolers in his local community, allowing them to form a personal relationship with their neighborhood. Beler recently arranged for Gotham to paint the exterior of a pizzeria in Brownsville – aptly called “Villains Hideout.” Like his elementary mentees at P.S. 9 and P.S. 321, his affection for his older students intensifies as his objectives substantialize.
“People always ask me, ‘why don’t you have children?’ Beler deplored. “I say, ‘I have plenty of kids. Trust me.’’
At Underhill Walls, Beler continually innovates unique methods to fuse street art with his fervor for education. He plans to deconstruct a recently completed Kobe Bryant memorial mural and donate the panel to Gotham, where it’ll either be auctioned to charity or kept for decoration. Settling into a steady routine, he now switches walls every autumn and spring, curating themes like Album Covers and Urban Jungle. His relationship with the building’s owner remains in good standing, under the stipulation Beler includes his grandson in at least one composition in all Underhills going forward. When I last visited, I saw the smiling child integrated into a panel Beler collaborated on with his students.
“I talked to Gotham’s principal recently, and he told me: ‘you’ve opened our eyes as to what can be done to improve a community,’” Beler recounted. ‘You’ve shown us what other neighborhoods could have.’”
I’ve admired Beler’s conviction since the first time I saw him in action. Possessing the dexterity equipped to deal with elementary-aged children and a diverse selection of muralists takes years to sharpen, though one could argue the two tasks are sometimes synonymous. When I asked him how he stays sane, Beler attributed his achievements to his permanent grin, even despite several obstacles. Yet his success is also rooted in a paradoxical personality: his ability to boast both unwavering patience and firm authority. It’s a struggle many educators are familiar with. Beler embraces his proteges with humanity in one instant, radiating warmth from his kind blue eyes. In the next, he offers critique, pushing individuals to challenge themselves beyond fixed limits. I expected no less when I decided to write this story.
Jeff Beler urges others to pursue potentiality regardless of perceivable proficiency. While he often receives scrutiny for selecting the same muralists, his bias isn’t grounded in malice. If Beler takes someone under his wing, he’s forming a bond he hopes to nurture for the foreseeable future. Growth is an inevitable byproduct of repeated business, and he’s forged a close communion with each individual he works with. When many move on to seek other endeavors, they do so knowing Beler is never too difficult to locate. He’s embedded his role as a street art stalwart, a fixture onto which a changing district can cling to. As Prospect Heights finds its footing among New York’s gentrified balance, Beler continues his mission within its expanding parameters, bringing him back to where his community began.
On that familiar corner near Washington Avenue, inspiring the next generation of Brooklyn artists.
This article was originally published in UP’s Issue 3: Community & Culture, published Ocober 2020. Order a copy here & read it in print!
Christina Elia is a freelance journalist and personal essayist from New York City who writes about fine art, photography, and travel. Her work has been published online in Observer, Apartment Therapy, and i-D Magazine, and has appeared in print in SixtySix Magazine and Graffiti Art Magazine.
![]()








