UP3 - Quarantine: A Litmus Test for Creatives

Written by Vittoria Benzine

This Article Originally Appeared in UP Issue 3: Community & Culture – Published in 2021

Order a Copy and Read it in Print!

“This is not a vacation, it’s a tragedy.” I read that on Tumblr a few days after COVID-19 confined me to my apartment. I kept repeating the quote to myself, a constant reminder that no matter how badly I’d needed this break, no matter how dreamlike isolation felt, I should be wary of celebrating the quarantine that accompanied Spring 2020’s coronavirus pandemic. My relief felt incorrect amongst the panic and economic fallout that had ensued.

I noticed other puzzling responses emerge from a populace coping with unprecedented times. Just before New York City entered ‘PAUSE’ at Governor Cuomo’s behest, as most of the city’s denizens sequestered themselves into a self-imposed isolation in an effort to ‘flatten the curve,’ New Yorkers seemingly self-divided into emotional camps. People I knew who worked in offices, those likely to favor corporate music festivals and spend Sundays at brunch, lamented the unhappiness associated with isolation. Artists, on the other hand, touted that their entire lives had trained them for this moment. “I had no idea my lifestyle was called quarantine,” one meme echoed, posted by artists well-adapted to staying indoors and trudging through commissioned work. Creatives, as they asserted, thrived on unstructured alone time.

You can probably guess, by virtue of my position with this magazine, which outlook I favored. 

I only pick sides when necessary, suspicious of the inclination to view life on binary terms. There is always a gray area. For myself, quarantine came at the pivotal moment, just before I would have lost touch with reality. January, February, and the first half of March had me working at a sprinter’s pace, running away from the discomfort and anxiety that had characterized my 2010s towards the accomplishment and peace I hope to find with the 2020s. 

“My relief felt incorrect amongst the panic and economic fallout that had ensued.”

I spent those last months of winter edging toward self-destruction in the name of self-improvement. One week before quarantine, I blocked out a four-day window to spend at home in Pennsylvania, hopeful that the prospect of a vacation would buoy my inexorable push forward. When I got the call that my sustenance job would be closed for the next two weeks, my dinky plans paled in comparison with the swath of relaxation set before me. Like a woman in convalescence, langouring days away in pajamas was an act worth celebrating. It meant recovery, productive in its own way.

Each morning, I thanked the stars for my good fortune. If ever there was a moment to be forcibly driven indoors, this was the most opportune one. I lived in the apartment of my dreams. I loved my roommates and cherished the Dalmatian that had become our house mascot. I was more involved with my craft than ever before, reading and writing thousands of words each day out of zest rather than sole duty. My family was healthy. I had money in the bank, and more coming, as my job promised to pay for the first month of quarantine.

Others, I knew, were not so lucky on any number of these fronts. After all, it was a tragedy, not a vacation.

Street artists appeared especially vulnerable to the circumstances, at first blush. These artists make their money painting outside – murals and gates and other facades they’re commissioned to adorn. Art enthusiasts were heading indoors, businesses were closing, and there would be no more gallery openings or group shows, in accordance with social distancing measures. 

Street artists appeared especially vulnerable to the circumstances, at first blush.

Rather than allowing their shine to dim, creative individuals across the country interpreted COVID-19 as a call to arms. I was inspired by the hustle splashed across Instagram as street artists pushed their artwork, merchandise, and personal brands with renewed vigor. These artists even provided their talents free of charge in an effort to help mankind cope with this new normal, drawing coloring books and posting new content. They organized virtual events to have their work seen in collective efforts. Every new endeavor proved that beautiful things can come from trying times. 

Meanwhile, I found new ways to stress myself out. I immediately set to work writing an article documenting this unprecedented moment, weeks before what would have been UP’s third issue print deadline e. I conducted nine interviews that first week. Everything felt great, like I was making moves to spite tragedy. 

My mood mingled relaxation and stress with suspicion. I had my doubts about sensationalism across the news, as did many of the artists I spoke with – a testament to the dismal state of trust in privatized reporting. Artist Stephanie Grajales said she started taking the illness seriously “when I saw the fear in people’s eyes.” Lexi Bella also believed the frenzy was baseless until she learned another artist in her circle had contracted COVID-19. Before shutting herself in, she endeavored to paint one more gate, at Bushwick’s 3rd Ethos Art Gallery. 

Rather than allowing their shine to dim, creative individuals across the country interpreted COVID-19 as a call to arms.

Queens-based artist Cernesto repeated this sentiment. Prior to social distancing, he had one final piece of business to attend to. He’d been commissioned to paint inside a hair salon near the Metro North’s Bronxville station. Cern explained that the owner had arranged the commission “prior to New York City’s alerts and alarms and precautions.” The artist and his patron agreed to continue despite the mounting fever pitch, handling their proceedings very carefully. The owner shuttled Cern between the city and salon, and Cern completed his work in isolation, alone in the empty establishment. “On a creative level that was something I really wanted to do, [we] had already discussed something and it was, inspiring and exciting for both of us, so I wanted to make it happen.”

Cern also recognized the project’s financial importance. “I’d been in touch with other people around the world, so I could already see where we were going. It was very obvious how things were about to get here,” the artist intimated. He figured that he better “get this one commission, because who knows the next time anyone will be able to be working.” 

“On a creative level that was something I really wanted to do, [we] had already discussed something and it was, inspiring and exciting for both of us, so I wanted to make it happen.”

On my first day of isolation, I performed a livestream reading for Left Bank Magazine’s Live Festival. Founder and organizer Kristyn Potter told me in a later interview that she wanted the festival to serve as “a response to what was going on.” Potter continued, “mostly, it was a way to get everyone to not feel so alone and celebrate their art and distract themselves for a bit.” As a writer and editor for Left Bank, the publication she founded to cover music and culture, Potter has a voracious appreciation for the power of multiple art forms. 

We both had the sense that we’d been incredibly naive to the havoc COVID-19 would wreak. From our more informed vantage point, after the festival, Potter noted, “it was really good for what we needed it to do, but I don’t think anything could or can truly combat emotionally what’s going on.”

 

Potter told me, “I still feel really scared and overwhelmed, confused. I’m a little nervous about the future plans that I made, nervous about money.”

 

Anxiety appeared the predominant emotion this pandemic spurred, particularly for the sake of loved ones. Grajales explained that she worried about her mother “because she’s still going to work. Her job is essential. She’s a concierge for a luxury apartment building so she runs the front desk. She suffers from asthma.”

UP photographer and contributor Ana Candelaria stopped venturing out for photos. “I don’t feel comfortable going out because I live with my mom, who’s elderly,” Candelaria said. She made a final run to stockpile as many photos as possible to sustain her Instagram during the hiatus. “I did notice some new work in Freeman’s Alley,” she reported. “Not so much throughout the Lower East Side mural-wise, but wheatpaste-wise, yes, there was some new work. It all related to COVID-19.”

Street artist Eyebrows stopped putting pieces up in the streets. “I’m dying to go out because it’s the perfect time,” he pined. New York’s empty sidewalks and alleyways were ripe for wheatpasting and stickering. Concern for his family roped him indoors though, as he continued, “I don’t want to come home with anything… I feel like going out right now is a risk more than a reward.”

Fortunately, staying inside came with benefits. Eyebrows remarked, “I’ve got so much shit done, it’s unbelievable. I’m living like an artist. That’s the dream, you know. I never want to go back.” He mentioned that he’d watched my thirty-minute set for Left Bank Live in full. “If you posted that and it was a normal workday, maybe I wouldn’t have paid as much attention as I did… I had the time, I didn’t have the distractions, and it wasn’t like I had six different things pressing on me to do. I was able to sit down and watch.”

“I’ve got so much shit done, it’s unbelievable. I’m living like an artist. That’s the dream, you know. I never want to go back.”

Grajales sympathized. “When you have a nine to five, you can’t really put all of your energy into your artwork. A lot of people are able to be home because they’re laid off,” she noted. “There’s a huge spike in depression, anxiety,” Grajales continued, “but I see a lot of people resorting to coloring, drawing, or just enjoying artwork.” For herself, she explained, “I feel incredibly blessed to be able to have my art as my therapy.”

In the absence of taking photos, Candelaria switched gears as well. “Editing makes me happy. I go through my photos and it brings me joy to dress them up and all that jazz. That’s what I’ve been doing to take my mind off of not being able to walk and photograph,” she told me.

An established artist amongst New York’s streets, Bella also jumped at the opportunity for a tone shift. “I’m really excited to focus on my oil painting,” she smiled. While springtime normally brings an onslaught of outdoor painting, oil painting is Bella’s original muse. She studied the medium while at art school in Philadelphia. Last year, she travelled to Rome for Kickfest. Seeing the modern painters and the old masters there inspired her to return to her roots. 

“Even though I like to do commissions, it’s still work,” Bella continued. “It still takes away from my time in the studio.” She reiterated the statement that quarantine could prove a blessing to creative people, or at least an opportunity to utilize their devotion to their craft. “Sometimes we wish we had a reason to quarantine ourselves, so it’s really more of a retreat. Whereas people I know who are nine to fivers… they’re more frustrated about this idea of having extra time, whether it’s for introspection or creation. I feel like the people who are more panicked are the ones who are not creators as their vocation.”

Speaking with Cern, I wondered if the surrounding tone of chaos had seeped into his work. Instead, he eschewed the media’s influence, in an effort to “activate different kinds of languages and different things that I hope transcend myself, and hope transcend a momentary lapse in awareness or presence of a larger life force.” Rather than capitulating to fear, Cern sought to “be aware of the angels that come through, the light that does try to shine.”

“Sometimes we wish we had a reason to quarantine ourselves, so it’s really more of a retreat. Whereas people I know who are nine to fivers… they’re more frustrated about this idea of having extra time, whether it’s for introspection or creation”

Idealistic at heart, Cern seemed reticent to utilize this period to increase sales or expand his reach. “From my nature, I’ve had yet to ever get awesome at business…We’ll see if this makes me a salesman,” he responded to my giggles. “I hope not necessarily to be better at business, but to make my work more accessible because I have more time to do the mundane organization.”

 

Of all the anxiety that COVID-19 unleashed, the bulk of it centered around financial insecurity. Eyebrows was concerned for the city’s already struggling small businesses. Making use of his newfound free time, he partnered with East Village Vintage Collective to distribute vintage clothing that would be painted by artists he knew and auctioned online. “Small businesses are taking a hit because they’ve gotta close their doors, and they might not survive it. If it goes down for three months, a lot of small businesses are gonna be closing, especially in the East Village where rent is crazy,” Eyebrows said.

Grajales relayed her plan to host “a whole bunch of different virtual events to connect women.” I was a feature for one of these livestreams and enjoyed discussing the new insights into writing that I’d gleaned. A veritable authority on livestreaming per her experience, Potter told me “livestreaming is a very democratic and accessible way to connect with people.” The scale of these events makes a difference though, and Potter held the belief that intimate affairs would prove more comforting. She explained, “it’s really important to connect with community, and it’s really important for that community to stay authentic…The point is to make you feel closer and not more separate.”

 

Livestreams and the countless virtual events that arose while waiting for the storm to pass replaced those public institutions where daily life once played out. In everyday existence, galleries are typically the forum where creatives congregate to exchange ideas and pleasantries, to update each other on their careers and bear witness to colleagues’ artistic development. COVID-19 eliminated these spaces by shuttering brick-and-mortar operations. Business obeys primal laws favoring adaptation. Several newfound gallery organizations, structured specifically on principles of innovation, stood to make the most of COVD-19’s strange reality. 

Formally founded in August 2018, Trotter & Sholer is a rootless gallery; as co-founder Jenna Ferrey explained, they host “pop up shows around the city and smaller intimate showings in private apartments.” Thanks to this model, they avoided the pitfall of paying rent. “We decided for our business model at the beginning that we couldn’t afford the overhead of a permanent physical space,” Farrey said. “That’s a blessing.” 

Online gallery service Eazel has also had its hands full satisfying the vacant need for artists to show their work despite the closure of public spaces. Eazel uses top of the line technology to digitally map and provide a realistic gallery experience for users across the web. Viewers can virtually enter one of Eazel’s affiliate galleries from around the globe and click around the space as if they were walking through it. The image quality is spectacular, and aids in the suspension of disbelief. 

Eazel began in Seoul, South Korea, when CEO Eric Yoon was injured while serving in the military. Eazel’s Global Account Manager Angie Phrasavath explained that Yoon “was in the hospital for almost a year.” Raised in a family of art collectors, the recovering enthusiast was dismayed to discover there was no optimal way to experience art remotely. He started Eazel five years ago in an effort to satisfy this need. 

Eazel’s model felt tailor-made for the stipulations attached to social distancing. Business skyrocketed as a result. “Since this pandemic, it’s been crazy,” Phrasavath said. “The amount of requests and inquiries that our company has received has been pretty wild.” She noted the greatest number of requests from the United States came from New York and Los Angeles. 

Eazel’s greater ethos aspires to teach dilettantes and laypeople that galleries are open to everyone. “When I first entered the art world, I was definitely intimidated to go into those galleries because I wasn’t seen as a collector,” Phrasavath recalled. Real life carries a litany of pesky expectations with it, and people can find it hard to explore their interests in the presence of so many wandering eyes. It will be interesting to see if the private time offered by quarantine initiates a wave of new art enthusiasts.

I asked Ferrey how she thought this time would influence the greater art world moving forward. “If this lasts as long as some people are predicting,” she replied, “it will have a profound social effect, and that will be reflected in what artists make and what they’re thinking about and what they’re processing and dealing with.” 

Bella validated this belief, positing that artists typically serve to “record and reflect history and through that reflection, can give hope, can brighten up people’s lives, can make them think about things they wouldn’t normally think about.”

Grajales espoused that artists “should definitely take advantage of this time to use social media and technology to share our work, because once we come out of this, you’re going to have a whole huge net.” Grajales continued, “maybe your story will help somebody else share their story. It creates a domino effect. We can all help each other out of this, because there are still people suffering more than others and they need someone.”

Potter reflected upon the moral fortitude of art in this moment. “We will create art more frequently than we have been able to,” she asserted. She also predicted the situation’s gravity would influence that art’s subject matter. “If you’re still self-aware, there’s no way you can write about some hot guy you’re pining over when people are dying and your friends are losing jobs. I think art will all have a lot more depth to it.”

Artists “should definitely take advantage of this time to use social media and technology to share our work, because once we come out of this, you’re going to have a whole huge net.”

In terms of the industry itself, Bella considered that this situation would “thin the herd.” She explained, “a lot of people who were like, ‘I’m gonna move [to New York] and work in a restaurant and [try] to make it,’ and they’re just not going to be able to sustain it… It’s challenging, it is survival of the fittest, and it does force people to take it seriously or get out of the way.”

Eyebrows worried that the same shift at play within general business, where smaller, independent organizations are capitulating to the powers of larger ones, might take hold in the art world. “If our economy crashes,” he mused, “then everybody’s gonna be an artist because there’s nothing left for you to fucking do.”

Grajales, though, was optimistic that this era of reflection would benefit society in the long run, helping people understand “how we’ve lost a lot of humanity due to social media.” Where technology once separated us from loved ones, distracting us at dinner tables and baiting us from genuine connection with convenient but detached texts, it’s now the only tool left at our disposal to bridge the gaps of isolation. As a result, Grajales thought, “everybody’s going to come out of this with a new set of eyes and a repaired heart. We are all going to be more compassionate towards each other. Because you see how frail and how really precious life is.”

Candelaria noted, “when I went out, I felt like a reporter, like one of those people after the war zone, after smoke is cleared.” Because she is native New Yorker, I wondered if she ever thought she’d witness an event like this. “Never in my lifetime,” she responded. “I wouldn’t even think I would experience something like this, to the point where everything has been completely shut down business-wise, the schools. It’s dramatic. It really is.”

One thing I learned from quarantine: never call the game in the first quarter. Anything can change. Life is not static. Where the first week felt like a fresh wave of relief, the weeks that followed brought me to the brink of relapse and depression. I’d previously fancied myself another creative individual who thrived in contemplation. I never realized how profoundly I relied on activity to distract from inner turmoil.

Everyone I spoke with brought their own personality to the table, with their own fears and dreams. It’s been marvelous to witness how these borders of separation have dissolved despite the physical distance. As creatives, we seem to have worked through our private concerns in the online digital sphere, sharing work and thoughts over posts and stories. I am grateful for everyone I’m connected with, for the ability to bear witness alongside them to this historical moment.

As I’m writing the conclusion to this article, I’m cresting into week five of quarantine. To say resignation characterizes my state would lend a misplaced air of emptiness, of giving up. Having been indoors for thirty-five days straight, I’ve noticed the intricacies of my internal monologue. My landscape has become more peaceful. I once sought to diminish the effects of sadness and anxiety through sheer activity, a ceaseless stream of shifts at work, interviews, gallery openings and exercise classes. Now I find myself laying in bed, watching the flickering of candles, and riding out those feelings’ full courses. 

The words still flow from my fingers, though not nearly as often as I welcome them in from books. When I write, it is to express rather than accomplish. I am grateful to have this method of expression, as so many of the artists I spoke with mentioned regarding their art. I will be most grateful though, if I can carry the realizations and memories of this absurd period through the rest of my life. I trust this experience will inform my work moving forward, as it will for so many other creatives. Most of all, I hope that this shared experience enriches our society, pushing us towards a new value system that brings peace on a greater scale.

Vittoria Benzine is a street art journalist and personal essayist based in Brooklyn, New York. Her affinity for counterculture and questioning has introduced her to exceptional artists and morally ambiguous characters alike. She values writing as a method of processing the world’s complexity. Send love letters to her via:

Insta: @vittoriabenzine

Site: vittoriabenzine.com

Email: vittoriabenzine@gmail.com