The Keep: Brooklyn’s Cabinet of Curiosities

Written by Leigh Pennington
Published on November 4th, 2025
Those of us who have a storied regularity with The Keep can confirm that this is the first and last word in Brooklyn establishments that can make its patrons feel like they are drinking in an artist salon of yore, that’s as comfortable as hanging out in your living room (but with better cocktails and a smoking patio). For those who have yet to visit the antique festooned, dimly lit, and slightly haunted establishment on Cypress and Starr Avenue in Ridgewood, be ready to step into a world of nostalgia, art, music, magic, community, and cocktails.
Built from the ground up by Diego and Stephanie Castillo, the genesis of The Keep began with the pair’s history as a couple. Diego Castillo was born in Mexico and came to New York at the age of 22 after residing in Montreal the year prior. Stephanie was born in the States but lived abroad in several different countries including Italy, England, and Nigeria before returning to New York. Diego had previously worked at a number of noted establishments in the New York service industry including Heights Cafe and Lucky Strike. At the time, Stephanie too worked at Heights Cafe as a waitress/manager.

Diego recalls the first time he laid eyes on his soon to be wife, best friend, and business partner. “When I met her, I was like, oh my god, so beautiful. She was 10 years older than me…From the first day, we started chatting…she was really mystical, magical…I tell people that I miss her a lot because she was kind of like my mom too. She was my wife. She was my everything, my other half.”
The couple lived together in several Brooklyn neighborhoods before purchasing a house in Ridgewood, just a short block or two away from the property that would become The Keep. Stephanie had wanted to open a bar of their own for some time and the pair had made another previous attempt with a property in Carol Gardens, however the deal fell through. Diego recalled, “I saw that she was a little bit sad. So after that, I was like, Okay, I need to make it happen. This place (The Keep property) was empty for two years. And again, she said, ‘Come on, let’s do it. We can do it.’ She always wanted this for me. So we came to check the place, and it needed a lot of work. It didn’t have any electricity. The pipes were broken. It was an old building.”
In addition to the heavy level of work needed to revive the property, Diego and Stephanie had just used all their money to purchase the house in Ridgewood. However with Stephanie as the dreamer and Diego the believer they were determined to make their vision a reality. Through savvy, effort, bartering, and community involvement they transformed an old and somewhat derelict building into a worthy bar. Diego called in a number of favors with friends and old colleagues offering to pay for construction, electric, plumbing, and air conditioning work in installments. Stephanie secured $10,000 dollars in funds by selling her art work.
Money was not the only issue that needed to be conquered. When Diego and Stephanie first rented the property they were told that the space could not serve any beverages, not even coffee. Back in the day the site was a dance hall and had a somewhat nefarious history with the neighborhood residents. Diego recalled, “I believe somebody got stabbed there. That person died. So then all the neighbors got together and they shut down the place. So this place was not supposed to be able to get a liquor license at all. We had a meeting at one of the churches for a liquor license with the community board. The president of the community board, her name was Andy Maggio, which is Italian. My wife was Italian as well. She could speak Italian perfectly. She went to the meeting, and she met the woman, and she started talking, the lady asked her, ‘Where do you live?’ And she said, ‘I live at 1707 Willoughby Avenue.’ The woman that used to live there, Mina Roupp, who sold us a house, used to babysit for her. So that was the whole connection. Right there they clicked, and she told Stephanie, ‘Don’t worry, I’m gonna make sure they give you the liquor license.’”
With a newly restored space and a liquor license in hand Stephanie began to adorn the bar with The Keep’s signature antique apparel. She collected pieces during her travels throughout Europe as well as the US. Diego went along on some of these trips. “Before I met her, she would go upstate, or she would go to a place like Kansas. Sometimes we would fly on a plane to Kansas, and then we would rent a Uhaul, and we would drive back, stopping in places where they would have antiques. We would buy some and then we would just keep going.”
Through savvy, effort, bartering, and community involvement they transformed an old and somewhat derelict building into a worthy bar.
The type of curio to be found on nearly every surface, mounted on walls, or hanging from the ceiling includes: taxidermy, vintage mirrors and cabinets, tapestries, toys, pedestals, portraits, a Peewee Herman puppet, armor, helmets, farming tools, chandeliers, weapons, clocks, an army of candles, religious statues, and much more. You could pick out something new to observe every single visit. Diego explained, “It is beautiful. It was her (Stephanie’s) dream. This is the inside of her head.”
Add to that a killer cocktail menu/full bar, a loyal and skilled staff, as well as a host of artists that have come to represent The Keep just as much as the treasures that adorn the space, and what was once conceived as a bar has since become a family club house of the bohemian bizarre. Aidan O’Grady has worked as a bartender at The Keep since the early years. He recalled, “My friend Nick was working at The Keep. I came for the opening night. I remember thinking ‘this place has a bit of magic to it.’ It was full of all sorts of characters, all buzzing around the place. Six months later Nick moved back to California. Stephanie then gave me a shot, what was meant to be a few months behind the bar turned into 11 years of friendships, laughter, and some nights I will never forget. Stephanie was family. The Keep has been a big part of my life.”
Since the beginning jazz has been a central component of The Keep’s history. Diego recounted, “Adrian and Tatiana, they were a couple. They used to live not far from here. Adrian plays the violin, and Tatiana is a singer. They had some really good energy. For her (Stephanie), it was all about energy. As soon as we opened, they started playing every single Wednesday. I think it was pretty much the first bar in Ridgewood or Bushwick that was playing jazz.”
Over the years the space has come to be adopted by generations of jazz musicians. One in particular, singer/songwriter Hannah Gil, has considered the Keep a place of comfort and community for several years. She recalled, “It was nuts, because there would be lines of saxophone players and singers, waiting to sit in and it was just a party. Swing dancers would come after their gigs…It feels like a true New York experience. So many of those are closed now, like Anyway Cafe, Vivaldi in Greenwich Village. I used to be really obsessed with a specific era of New York growing up. There’s something about this space that makes young me very happy, because it reminds me of those books that I read where somebody would just walk into a space and all of a sudden be surrounded by artists and cheap drinks and cigarettes. So there’s something that makes my little kid heart very happy about all the temptation. You know, like La Vie Boheme in Rent and the Kit Kat Club in Cabaret, pre-Nazis.” Even when Gil is not performing she can usually be found posted up in the back, enjoying a pint of Guiness and puffing on a hand rolled cigarette.
It feels like a true New York experience… There’s something about this space that makes young me very happy, because it reminds me of those books that I read where somebody would just walk into a space and all of a sudden be surrounded by artists and cheap drinks and cigarettes.
In addition to sitting in on a number of performances, Gil has also performed some of her own original music at The Keep. “I moved here (New York) to do original music. I just kind of entered a chapter in my life where I was really excited to do the jazz stuff, and now I want to get back into doing my original music. So when Diego offered every fourth Thursday of the month, I was like, I don’t want this to just be another jazz gig. This is a perfect opportunity to start putting my stuff out again. So the first set is all original music and the second set is jazz.” One of the original tunes, ‘The Wolves in the Tree Line’, is on Gil’s most recently released album Spooky Jazz Volume III (go listen to the album on Spotify).
Musicians as well as visual artists derive a great deal of inspiration, belonging, and repose from The Keep’s magnetic influence. On Mondays you can catch a large group posted up on the back patio drawing and sketching on entire tables while passing a joint around. The space is also awash with tags and stickers belonging to graffiti and street artists. One of the most prominent being the “eye-know” tag of noted Brooklyn street artist Isabelle Ewing on the outer side of the back door.

Ewing has worked at The Keep for the last few months as a bartender and explained the attraction the bar has for artists living and working in Brooklyn. “You can tell that there’s so much love and energy that went into building that place, but also it is right next door to all the studios.” She has also approached Diego with an idea to place an in memorial mural to Stephanie on the side of the Chinese restaurant which shares the same building as The Keep. She envisions a large portrait of Stephanie and her pet duck (an escapee from a live poultry establishment on Starr street). Ewing also intends to host art nights and scavenger hunts on Sundays with friend and fellow artist Isabel Sierra, better known as The Love Whip.
One of the defining principles of The Keep is “it’s the kind of place where you can experiment and not feel like you’re being judged.” Diego and Stephanie have allowed The Keep to be used as a workshop and stage for a host of performers. Diego explained, “That was her (Stephanie’s) whole thing. She always wanted to make the place a lot different than any other bars around here. She wanted to have a special place where there was something to see; magic, burlesque.”
One of the defining principles of The Keep is that “it’s the kind of place where you can experiment and not feel like you’re being judged.”
On select nights you can even have your tarot cards read by resident card reader and glowing baton twirler The Oracle Electric. There are also some more out of the box spectacles to behold. Diego listed a few such as, “Georgio the carpet man. One day he came, and asked, ‘Do you mind if I just lay on the floor with a carpet over me, and people stand on me, and I said, okay…There was this other kid that came too and he’s like, ‘Do you mind if I just walk around naked and people can paint on my body?’ And I’m like, ‘Sure. Why not?’”
The anything goes aura for which The Keep is known can also be found in the supernatural. It is a well heard rumor that The Keep does indeed play host to a number of spirits. One of whom Diego believes to be the ghost of a mobster that was killed on site back in the 60s when the property was the Cypress Garden Restaurant. There have been a number of sightings over the years and on one occasion an attempted summoning of a well known spirit conducted by Ewing and Beckenstein in the basement.
Diego and Stephanie Castillo established not only a great bar, but a home away from home for all of Brooklyn’s misfit toys; a locus of unbridled joy, character, and heart.
From the tangible to the metaphysical The Keep functions as a cabinet of curiosities. The bar celebrated its 11th anniversary this past Halloween which seems fitting if not fated. It is a place where the veil between reality and fantasy is lifted. Eccentricity is fostered then washed down with a dirty martini. Diego and Stephanie Castillo established not only a great bar, but a home away from home for all of Brooklyn’s misfit toys; a locus of unbridled joy, character, and heart.
In loving memory of Stephanie Castillo, wife, friend, and mother of misfits.
Leigh Pennington – Hailing from Richmond Virginia, Leigh Pennington has lived, worked and studied around the world. She earned her BA in Anthropology, Art History, and Religion from Concordia University in Montreal. Last year she moved to New York to pursue a Masters in Oral History at Columbia University. Prior to moving back to the US she earned her first Masters from the Hebrew University of Jerusalem in Jewish Studies. Currently Leigh works as a freelance culture content writer as well as an Op-Ed editor for the Times of Israel. Her writing has been published in major news and opinion media such as Quebec Heritage News, Tablet Magazine and Lilith Magazine.
Instagram: @lb_pennington